Topic Actions

Topic Search

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Google [Bot] and 35 guests

Postwar Conversations

Join us in talking discussing all things Honor, including (but not limited to) tactics, favorite characters, and book discussions.
Re: Postwar Conversations
Post by saber964   » Sat Dec 13, 2014 6:15 pm

saber964
Admiral

Posts: 2423
Joined: Thu Dec 13, 2012 8:41 pm
Location: Spokane WA USA

cthia wrote: quote="SWM"[quote="cthia"]

Another conversation that just has to take place, if it hasn't, and I felt sorry for both Estelle Matsuko and Honor for the way this went down.

After Honor was victorious On Basilisk Station, Fearless had taken a whipping, and Honor didn't have time, or intact communications to touch bases with Estelle, to let her know she had survived. Textev states that Estelle hadn't even known who was the victor. In retrospect, I don't see why Reliant couldn't dispatch a report to the system governor.

At any rate, Estelle is going to tell Honor, in a mushy scene, how very worried she was about her. And probably something along the lines of, "Don't every do that to me again!"

If Michelle is around that fireplace, she'll add a certain "Seems she has a nasty little habit of doing that to her loved ones."

Actually, the textev says that no one knew there had even been a battle, because the Saladin was jamming their comms. And after Saladin was in no condition to jam the comms anymore, the Fearless was in no condition to even provide life support, let alone comms. It wasn't until a ship came out to track them down that anyone knew for sure that there had even been a battle. I think we can be confident that Estelle knew what had happened as quickly as anyone else outside of the rescue ships, since the story of the battle is vital information for the governor of a system under imminent threat of attack.[/quote]


****** *

"Status?"

"All stations manned, Captain," the exec said crisply. "Impeller wedge coming up—we should have movement capability in another ten minutes. Sirius has been underway for six-point-eight minutes . . . at four hundred and ten gees."

He paused, and Honor's jaw clenched. That was low for most warships, but impossibly fast for a freighter, and it confirmed Santos's deduction. Only military impellers could have produced that kind of acceleration for a ship Sirius's size . . . and only a military grade inertial compensator could allow her crew to survive it.

"The courier boat?" Her voice was sharp, and McKeon frowned.

"She started powering her wedge just after we did, Ma'am."
"Understood." Honor looked over her shoulder. "Do we have a link to the Resident Commissioner, Mr. Webster?"
"Yes, Ma'am."

"Put it on my screen." Honor looked back down just as a pale-faced Dame Estelle appeared. The commissioner opened her mouth, but Honor raised a hand and spoke first. "Excuse me, Dame Estelle, but time is short. I think I know what's going on now. Have you heard anything more from your patrol?" Matsuko shook her head mutely, and Honor's face went more masklike still.

"Very well. I am dropping my Marines now." She shot a sideways glance at McKeon, and he nodded and hit an intercom key to give the order. "Aside from that, there's very little we can do for you, I'm afraid. And unless I miss my guess, we're going to have problems of our own soon enough."

"I understand," Dame Estelle broke in, "but there's something you should know before you do anything else, Captain."
Honor cocked her head and gestured for the commissioner to continue. "We picked up a transmission from the general area where our patrol went down just after we lost contact with Lieutenant Malcolm," Matsuko said quickly. "It was scrambled but not encrypted, and we just broke the scramble. The transmitter didn't identify himself, and he used a code name for his recipient, but we detected a transmission to the freighter from the Haven Consulate immediately afterward, so I think we know who it was intended for."

"What did it say?" Honor demanded. Dame Estelle didn't answer in words; she simply played the message off, and Honor's eyes went cold and flat as a male voice gasped over her com.

"Odysseus! It's Odysseus now, damn it! The frigging Shaman's lost his goddamned mind! They're boiling up out of the caves, and I can't hold them! The hopped-up bastards are kicking off right fucking now!"

A surflike roar of Medusan voices and the whiplash cracks of countless rifles echoed behind the words, and then the sounds cut off as Dame Estelle stopped the playback.

"Thank you, Dame Estelle," Honor said flatly. "I understand what's happening now. Good luck."

She killed the circuit and bent over her maneuvering display, ignoring McKeon as she punched in the parking orbit pattern and laid vectors across it. It was going to be close, but there was far less orbital traffic than there had been, and if she could pull it off . . .


"Impellers in three minutes, Ma'am," McKeon reported.

"Mr. Webster!"

"Yes, Ma'am?"

"Stand by to record a signal to Lieutenant Venizelos at Basilisk Control for immediate relay to Fleet HQ. Fleet scramble, no encryption. Priority One."

Heads turned, and Webster's swallow was clearly audible.
"Aye, aye, Ma'am. Standing by to record."

"'Mr. Venizelos, you will commandeer the first available Junction carrier to relay the following message to Fleet HQ. Message begins: Authentication code Lima-Mike-Echo-Niner-Seven-One. Case Zulu. I say again, Zulu, Zulu, Zulu. Message ends.'" She heard McKeon suck air between his teeth at her shoulder. "That is all, Mr. Webster," she said softly. "You may transmit at will." Webster said absolutely nothing for an instant, but when he replied, his voice was unnaturally steady.

"Aye, aye, Captain. Transmitting Case Zulu." There was another brief pause, then, "Case Zulu transmitted, Ma'am."

"Thank you." Honor wanted to lean back and draw a deep breath, but there was no time. The message she'd just ordered Webster to send and Venizelos to relay to Manticore was never sent in drills, not even in the most intense or realistic Fleet maneuvers. Case Zulu had one meaning, and one only: "Invasion Imminent."

"Captain, are you sure—?" McKeon began, but her raised hand stopped him.

And then there had been the long voyage home. The long, slow voyage that had seemed to crawl, for Fearless's communications had been out. There was no way to tell Dame Estelle or the Admiralty what had happened, who had won, or the price her people had paid. Not until Fearless limped brokenly back into Medusa orbit thirteen hours after she'd left it and a white-faced Scotty Tremaine brought his pinnace alongside her air-bleeding wreck.

I thought Honor made it clear to Dame Estelle that she'd be having trouble herself, soon, and that all she could further do to assist Estelle was to drop her Marines. Which she was doing even as she and Dame Estelle spoke. The battle raged on for quite some time which should have logically implied to Dame Estelle that something did indeed happen. My last post seems to imply that Honor was aware that Dame Estelle knew something had happened, and would be worried.

Also, Lieutenant Venizelos was at Basilisk Control when he received orders and acknowledgement of a Case Zulu. Surely he would have shared that with Dame Estelle? No?

Of course, this may all be subjective and dependent on how I personally assimilated it all.

But, I think I have to concede. All circumstantial.[/quote]



Basilisk Control is 10 LH from Medusa, this battle took place before FTL comms, so by the time Venizelos knew any thing the fight was all over and what was left of Fearless was limping back to Medusa orbit.
Top
Re: Postwar Conversations
Post by cthia   » Sat Dec 13, 2014 6:21 pm

cthia
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 14951
Joined: Thu Jan 23, 2014 1:10 pm

Vince wrote:For all those getting On Basilisk Station mixed up with The Honor of the Queen:

In On Basilisk Station, CL Fearless engaged the Peep Q-ship Sirius. "Excuse me, Skipper, but what do we know about this Sirius?" "She's big—a seven-point-six m-ton Astra-class" ship. "Captain Johan Coglin, People's Merchant Service, commanding."

While in The Honor of the Queen, CA Fearless engaged the Masadan BC Thunder of God, formerly the BC Saladin of the Peoples Republic of Haven. "He never thought of Thunder of God as Saladin these days, and he had to stop thinking of Principality as Breslau"

Edit: BC Reliant only appeared as the flagship of the relief force in The Honor of the Queen. In On Basilisk Station, the relief force was the entire Manticoran Home Fleet, but it did not arrive until after CL Fearless had limped back to the planet Medusa.

Each quote is taken from the book mentioned in the paragraph. All italics in the quotes are the author's.

Me guilty Vince. I cross those wires every time. I think you corrected me just a few days ago on this same issue. It's perhaps some sort of Freudian thing?, since both skirmishes happened in the same system. Anyways, I should know better, since OBS is the best Sci-Fi novel written in a series, in my book. It's certainly my favorite of the entire series.

My humble apologies, again.

Son, your mother says I have to hang you. Personally I don't think this is a capital offense. But if I don't hang you, she's gonna hang me and frankly, I'm not the one in trouble. —cthia's father. Incident in ? Axiom of Common Sense
Top
Re: Postwar Conversations
Post by Belial666   » Sat Dec 13, 2014 6:26 pm

Belial666
Commodore

Posts: 972
Joined: Fri Jun 17, 2011 7:26 pm

It should be noted that hundred-megaton-plus nuclear explosions are bright. Bright enough to be visible from as far away as terrestrial planets are, however briefly.


So the flashes probably were borderline-visible with the naked eye, at least from space. With a telescope with 80.000x useful magnification, the whole fight might just be visible from the planet, potentially.
Top
Re: Postwar Conversations
Post by roseandheather   » Sat Dec 13, 2014 6:47 pm

roseandheather
Admiral

Posts: 2056
Joined: Sun Dec 08, 2013 10:39 pm
Location: Republic of Haven

Belial666 wrote:It should be noted that hundred-megaton-plus nuclear explosions are bright. Bright enough to be visible from as far away as terrestrial planets are, however briefly.


So the flashes probably were borderline-visible with the naked eye, at least from space. With a telescope with 80.000x useful magnification, the whole fight might just be visible from the planet, potentially.


And now I have an image of Dame Estelle, glued to some sort of monitoring equipment, feeling her heart stop at every nuclear pinprick in the sky, barely able to eat or move, let alone sleep, until she knows the fate of her star system and the woman she now considers a true friend.

...I hate you so much right now.

*cries a lot*
~*~


I serve at the pleasure of President Pritchart.

Javier & Eloise
"You'll remember me when the west wind moves upon the fields of barley..."
Top
Re: Postwar Conversations
Post by cthia   » Sat Dec 13, 2014 8:29 pm

cthia
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 14951
Joined: Thu Jan 23, 2014 1:10 pm

Another conversation that simply must happen, in their salt-n-pepper days around an open fire, is Honor and Scotty. IIRC, it was Scotty who trotted after Honor and kept her from splattering Captain Williams' brains all over that mess hall, down on the planet, during the Battle of Blackbird.

I don't see Honor's career surviving that. Especially so early on.

Edit:
It took Major Ramirez and several other officers to help restrain Honor. Talk about not knowing your own strength!

Considering this. Young really did get a patch torn out of his hide one-on-one against Honor!

Son, your mother says I have to hang you. Personally I don't think this is a capital offense. But if I don't hang you, she's gonna hang me and frankly, I'm not the one in trouble. —cthia's father. Incident in ? Axiom of Common Sense
Top
Re: Postwar Conversations
Post by Vince   » Sat Dec 13, 2014 10:10 pm

Vince
Vice Admiral

Posts: 1574
Joined: Fri Apr 09, 2010 11:43 pm

cthia wrote:Another conversation that simply must happen, in their salt-n-pepper days around an open fire, is Honor and Scotty. IIRC, it was Scotty who trotted after Honor and kept her from splattering Captain Williams' brains all over that mess hall, down on the planet, during the Battle of Blackbird.

I don't see Honor's career surviving that. Especially so early on.

Edit:
It took Major Ramirez and several other officers to help restrain Honor. Talk about not knowing your own strength!

Considering this. Young really did get a patch torn out of his hide one-on-one against Honor!

Honor stopped Major Ramirez from smashing Captain Williams head. This was before she found out about what the Masadans did to the crew from Madrigal that was taken prisoner.
The Honor of the Queen, Chapter wrote:The glob of spittle hit the dead skin of her left cheek. She couldn’t feel it, and for just one moment she couldn’t quite believe it had happened, but Major Ramirez’s left arm shot out. Armored fingers twisted in the neck of the Masadan’s one-piece uniform, and exoskeletal muscles whined as he snatched Williams off his feet. He slammed him back against the wall like a puppet, and his right fist started forward.
“Major!” Honor’s voice cracked like a whip, and Ramirez diverted the blow in the nick of time. His gauntlet smashed into the stone wall beside Williams’ head like a mace, so hard flying stone chips cut the Masadan’s cheek, and the red-faced, strangling captain flinched aside with a gasp of terror.
“Sorry, Ma’am.” The major was white with fury as he muttered his apology—to Honor, not Williams—and dropped the Masadan. He rubbed his left hand on his equipment harness as if to scrub away contamination, and Sergeant Talon handed Honor a napkin from a dispenser on one of the mess tables. She wiped her numb face carefully, her eyes still on the major, and wondered if Williams truly understood how close to death he’d just come.

“I understand your feelings, Major,” she said quietly, “but these people are our prisoners.”
“Yes, Ma’am. I understand.” Ramirez drew a deep breath and turned his back on Williams while the captain wheezed for breath. “They’re scum, and one of them killed a medic trying to patch him up, but they’re our prisoners. I’ll remember that, Ma’am.”
“See that you do,” Honor said, but she laid her hand on his armored shoulder as she spoke, and he managed a brief smile.

***Snip Honor seeing what happened to Madrigal's crew that was taken prisoner***

Major Ramirez looked up as Captain Harrington came up the corridor.
“Captain, what shall I—?”
She brushed by him as if he hadn’t spoken. There was no expression at all on her face, but the right side of her mouth twitched violently, and her gun was in her hand.
“Captain? Captain Harrington!”
He reached out to grasp her arm, and she looked at him at last.
“Get out of my way, Major.” Each word was precisely, perfectly formed despite her crippled mouth. “Clean up this section. Find every one of our people. Get them out of here.”
“But—"
“You have your orders, Major,” she said in that same, chilled-steel tone, and twitched out of his grasp. She started up the corridor once more, and he stared after her helplessly.

She didn’t look up when she reached the Marines in the passageway. She just strode straight ahead, and they scattered like frightened children. Sergeant Talon’s squad started to fall in around her, but she waved them back with a savage chop of her hand and kept walking.
Lieutenant Tremaine stared after her, biting his lip. He’d heard about the discoveries the Marines had made. He hadn’t believed it at first—hadn’t wanted to believe it—but then the medics had carried Commander Brigham’s stretcher past him. He’d believed it then, and the Marines’ fury had been dwarfed by his own, for he knew Mercedes Brigham well. Very well, indeed.
The Captain said she wanted to be alone. She’d ordered everyone to leave her alone. But Scotty Tremaine had seen her face.
She turned a bend in the corridor, and his own face tightened with decision. He laid aside his plasma carbine and went hurrying after her.


***Snip***

Captain Williams looked up as if he felt her hatred, and his face paled. She walked towards him, shoving people out of her way, and the voice calling her name was even louder as its owner pushed and shoved through the crowd behind her.
Williams tried to twist away, but her left hand tangled in his hair, and he cried out in agony as she slammed his head back against the wall. His mouth worked, gobbling words she didn’t bother to hear, and her right hand pressed the muzzle against his forehead and began to squeeze.
Someone else’s hands locked on her forearm, shoving frantically, and the sharp, spiteful explosion of a pulser dart pocked the mess hall roof as her pistol whined. She wrenched at the hands on her arm, trying to throw whoever it was off, but they clung desperately, and someone was shouting in her ear.
More voices shouted, more hands joined the ones on her arm, dragging her back from Williams while the man sagged to his knees, retching and weeping in terror, and she fought madly against them all. But she couldn’t wrench free, and she went to her own knees as someone snatched the pistol from her grip and someone else gripped her head and forced it around.
“Skipper! Skipper, you can’t!” Scotty Tremaine half-sobbed, holding her face between his hands while tears ran down his cheeks. “Please, Skipper! You can’t do this—not without a trial!”

She stared at him, her detached mind wondering what a trial had to do with anything, and he shook her gently.
“Please, Skipper. If you shoot a prisoner without a trial the Navy—" He drew a deep breath. “You can’t, Ma’am, however much he deserves it.”
“No, she can’t,” a voice like frozen helium said, and a trace of sanity came back into Honor’s expression as she saw Admiral Matthews. “I came as soon as I heard, Captain,” he spoke slowly and distinctly, as if he sensed the need to break through to her, “but your lieutenant’s right. You can’t kill him.” She stared deep into his eyes, and something inside her eased as she saw the agony and shame—and fury—in his soul.
“But?” she didn’t recognize her own voice, and Matthews’ mouth twisted in contemptuous hate as he glared down at the sobbing Masadan captain.
“But I can. Not without a trial. He’ll have one, I assure you, and so will all the animals he turned loose on your people. They’ll be scrupulously, completely fair—and as soon as they’re over, this sick, sadistic piece of garbage and all the others responsible will be hanged like the scum they are.” He met her eye levelly, and his icy voice was soft.
“I swear that to you, Captain, on the honor of the Grayson Navy.”
Italics are the author's, boldface text is my emphasis.

Note that Major Ramirez was not mentioned as restraining Honor from blowing off Captain Williams' head, just Scotty Tremaine (by name) and other unnamed individuals. Major Ramirez was probably busy carrying out Honor's orders to evacuate everyone from the section they were in.
-------------------------------------------------------------
History does not repeat itself so much as it echoes.
Top
Re: Postwar Conversations
Post by n7axw   » Sat Dec 13, 2014 10:37 pm

n7axw
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 5997
Joined: Wed Jan 22, 2014 8:54 pm
Location: Viborg, SD

This incident is mentioned subsequently at least three times. On one of those occasions it is stated that by mutual unspoken consent, Honor and Scotty never discussed it. It is not hard to understand why.

Don
When any group seeks political power in God's name, both religion and politics are instantly corrupted.
Top
Re: Postwar Conversations
Post by cthia   » Sat Dec 13, 2014 10:41 pm

cthia
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 14951
Joined: Thu Jan 23, 2014 1:10 pm

Vince wrote:Note that Major Ramirez was not mentioned as restraining Honor from blowing off Captain Williams' head, just Scotty Tremaine (by name) and other unnamed individuals. Major Ramirez was probably busy carrying out Honor's orders to evacuate everyone from the section they were in.


Sorry again Vince. I didn't quite remember it that way either. I was going by the wiki. I thought I had missed something. I haven't gone back to do a reread to check it.

Wiki ...
Prior to surrendering after the Battle of Blackbird, he erased the memory banks of his base's computer. He was captured when a Royal Marine assault team from HMS Fearless captured Blackbird, and was held with other Masadan prisoners in the mess hall. Upon meeting Captain Honor Harrington for the first time, he spat in her face, causing Major Tomas Ramirez to pick him up and violently slam him against a wall.

Williams refused to help the Manticorans and, when Colonel Harris gave the location of the Madrigal's surviving crewmembers, became violent and spat out obscenities until Major Ramirez knocked him against the wall once again.

When Captain Harrington found out about the atrocities committed by Williams and his crew, she drew her sidearm and prepared to shoot him. It took Major Ramirez and several of her crew to restrain her.

Captain Williams and the other Masadan officers of Blackbird were being held to stand trial for what happened to the Madrigal survivors. They were later hanged on Grayson in Captain Harrington's presence. (HH2)


http://honorverse.wikia.com/wiki/Williams_(Masada)

Son, your mother says I have to hang you. Personally I don't think this is a capital offense. But if I don't hang you, she's gonna hang me and frankly, I'm not the one in trouble. —cthia's father. Incident in ? Axiom of Common Sense
Top
Re: Postwar Conversations
Post by Vince   » Sat Dec 13, 2014 10:59 pm

Vince
Vice Admiral

Posts: 1574
Joined: Fri Apr 09, 2010 11:43 pm

cthia wrote:
Vince wrote:Note that Major Ramirez was not mentioned as restraining Honor from blowing off Captain Williams' head, just Scotty Tremaine (by name) and other unnamed individuals. Major Ramirez was probably busy carrying out Honor's orders to evacuate everyone from the section they were in.


Sorry again Vince. I didn't quite remember it that way either. I was going by the wiki. I thought I had missed something. I haven't gone back to do a reread to check it.

Wiki ...
Prior to surrendering after the Battle of Blackbird, he erased the memory banks of his base's computer. He was captured when a Royal Marine assault team from HMS Fearless captured Blackbird, and was held with other Masadan prisoners in the mess hall. Upon meeting Captain Honor Harrington for the first time, he spat in her face, causing Major Tomas Ramirez to pick him up and violently slam him against a wall.

Williams refused to help the Manticorans and, when Colonel Harris gave the location of the Madrigal's surviving crewmembers, became violent and spat out obscenities until Major Ramirez knocked him against the wall once again.

When Captain Harrington found out about the atrocities committed by Williams and his crew, she drew her sidearm and prepared to shoot him. It took Major Ramirez and several of her crew to restrain her.

Captain Williams and the other Masadan officers of Blackbird were being held to stand trial for what happened to the Madrigal survivors. They were later hanged on Grayson in Captain Harrington's presence. (HH2)


http://honorverse.wikia.com/wiki/Williams_(Masada)

The best way I have found to check your memory of something in Baen Books is to have purchased the ebooks directly from Baen eBooks (or to have one of the CDs, for the books that are on them). That way you can get the RTF file, load it into a word processor and then use the word processor's search function to find the text that is of interest. It makes it fairly easy to copy and paste the text here on the forums as quoted text. And the text, unless David has made a mistake (the Great Resizing is an example), is more accurate than the wikis, although you sometimes have to check one book against a later one.
-------------------------------------------------------------
History does not repeat itself so much as it echoes.
Top
Re: Postwar Conversations
Post by SWM   » Sat Dec 13, 2014 11:45 pm

SWM
Fleet Admiral

Posts: 5928
Joined: Mon Jan 11, 2010 4:00 pm
Location: U.S. east coast

And it's not like you're the only one to misremember things. I've pulled some doozies. :D
--------------------------------------------
Librarian: The Original Search Engine
Top

Return to Honorverse